Borders of Time

Person

Eduard Bernstein

Eduard Bernstein was a German socialist who, at the end of the 19th century, argued that Marx had been wrong about the coming collapse of capitalism and that socialism should be built by democratic reform.

Historical figure · 1850 CE – 1932 CE

Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Image related to Eduard Bernstein
Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Born
6 January 1850, Berlin, Prussia
Died
18 December 1932, Berlin, Germany
Role
Social Democratic theorist, journalist and deputy
In office
Reichstag deputy, 1902–1906, 1912–1918, 1920–1928
Known for
Revisionism, or "evolutionary socialism"
Hear the whole article read aloud
Bernstein (on far right) at the Third Congress of the Second International in Zurich in 1893, with Friedrich Engels, Clara Zetkin, August Bebel, and others.
Herman Greulich (1842–1925) · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Bernstein (on far right) at the Third Congress of the Second International in Zurich in 1893, with Friedrich Engels, Clara Zetkin, August Bebel, and others.

Bernstein (on far right) at the Third Congress of the Second International in Zurich in 1893, with Friedrich Engels, Clara Zetkin, August Bebel, and others.

Herman Greulich (1842–1925) · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Eduard Bernstein was a German socialist who, at the end of the 19th century, argued that Marx had been wrong about the coming collapse of capitalism and that socialism should be built by democratic reform. His "revisionism" split the most powerful socialist party in Europe, the German Social Democratic Party (SPD), and set out much of the programme that democratic socialist and social democratic parties later followed. A close friend of Friedrich Engels, he spent 23 years in exile and lived just long enough to see the Weimar Republic begin to fall.

A bank clerk turns socialist

Title page of the 1906 edition of Die Voraussetzungen des Sozialismus und die Aufgaben der Sozialdemokratie (1899), also known as Evolutionary Socialism
Verlag J.H.W.Dietz Nachfolger · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Title page of the 1906 edition of Die Voraussetzungen des Sozialismus und die Aufgaben der Sozialdemokratie (1899), also known as Evolutionary Socialism

Title page of the 1906 edition of Die Voraussetzungen des Sozialismus und die Aufgaben der Sozialdemokratie (1899), also known as Evolutionary Socialism

Verlag J.H.W.Dietz Nachfolger · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Bernstein was born on 6 January 1850 in Schöneberg, then a village and now part of Berlin, in the Kingdom of Prussia. His father was a railway engine driver, and the family was Jewish but largely secular. Money was short, so at 16 he left school and started an apprenticeship at a bank, where he worked as a clerk from 1869 to 1878.

In 1872 he joined the Social Democratic Workers' Party, one of the two socialist parties that merged in 1875 to form what became the SPD. He was then more influenced by Ferdinand Lassalle and the philosopher Eugen Dühring than by Karl Marx.

Exile in Zurich and London

Bernstein in 1895
Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Bernstein in 1895

Bernstein in 1895

Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

In October 1878, a week or so before Otto von Bismarck's anti-socialist law came into force, Bernstein moved to Zurich as private secretary to a wealthy socialist sympathiser, Karl Höchberg. There he read Engels's book Anti-Dühring, which, as he later recalled, converted him to Marxism. In January 1881 the party leader August Bebel made him editor of Der Sozialdemokrat, the party newspaper, which was printed in Switzerland and smuggled into Germany. Engels called it the best paper the party had ever had.

In 1888 Bismarck pressed the Swiss government to expel the newspaper's staff, and Bernstein moved to London, his home for the next 13 years. He wrote for the party press, helped draft the practical sections of the SPD's Erfurt Programme of 1891, and became one of Engels's closest companions. When Engels died in 1895 he named Bernstein one of his literary executors.

Evolutionary socialism

Bernstein c. 1910s
Hermann Noack · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Bernstein c. 1910s

Bernstein c. 1910s

Hermann Noack · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Life in Victorian Britain changed Bernstein's thinking. He saw a capitalist economy that was stable rather than tottering, trade unions that won real gains, and the Fabian Society, a group of British socialists who believed in gradual change. From 1896 he published a series of articles in the party's theoretical journal arguing that key Marxist forecasts had not come true. In 1899 he gathered his arguments in a book translated into English as Evolutionary Socialism.

His case, put simply, was that capitalism was not heading for a final crash, the middle classes were not disappearing, and workers were not growing poorer. Socialism would therefore come, if it came at all, through the gradual extension of democracy and reform: votes, unions, cooperatives and laws, won within the existing system. He urged the party to admit that this was what it already did in practice and to reach out to the middle classes. Ethics, not historical inevitability, was for him the reason to be a socialist.

Uproar in the party

Bernstein in 1923
Agence Rol. Agence photographique (commanditaire) · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Bernstein in 1923

Bernstein in 1923

Agence Rol. Agence photographique (commanditaire) · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The SPD's leading theorist, Karl Kautsky, attacked the book, and so did the young Rosa Luxemburg, whose Social Reform or Revolution? became a classic reply. The party condemned revisionism at its congresses, first at Hanover in 1899 and again, more sharply, at Dresden four years later. In practice, though, many trade unionists and parliamentarians agreed with Bernstein, and the gap between the party's revolutionary language and its reforming behaviour remained.

An arrest warrant against him was allowed to lapse, and he returned to Germany in February 1901. The next year he was elected to the Reichstag for Breslau-West, and he sat there, with gaps, until 1928.

War and revolution

When World War I began, Bernstein voted with his party for war credits on 4 August 1914, a vote he later called the darkest day of his political life. He soon came to see the war as imperialist. With Kautsky and Hugo Haase he issued a peace manifesto, "The Demand of the Hour", in June 1915, and in April 1917 he was among the founders of the USPD, the Independent Social Democrats, who opposed the war.

During the German revolution of 1918–19 he worked in the Treasury of the provisional government. On Christmas Eve 1918 he took out SPD membership again, and in March 1919 he left the USPD. Against the mood of the nation, he told his party that Germany bore a large share of responsibility for the war and that the Treaty of Versailles had to be accepted.

Last years and legacy

Bernstein sat in the Reichstag of the Weimar Republic until 1928 and spent his last years warning against the enemies of the republic on the right and the communist left. He was a lifelong opponent of antisemitism, including inside the socialist movement. He died in Berlin on 18 December 1932, six weeks before Adolf Hitler became chancellor.

In his lifetime he lost the argument within his own party, and by his death he was no longer a leading figure. After World War II, however, the West German SPD dropped revolutionary Marxism and committed itself to democratic reform, very much along the lines he had drawn. Most of Europe's social democratic parties followed a similar road.

On our maps

Our 1878 map shows the new German Empire, Switzerland and the United Kingdom, the three countries of his working life. The 1930 map shows Weimar Germany in his final years.

Key dates

  1. 1850Born in Berlin into a Jewish railway worker's family.
  2. 1872Joins the Social Democratic Workers' Party while working as a bank clerk.
  3. 1878Moves to Zurich just before Bismarck's anti-socialist law comes into force.
  4. 1881Becomes editor of Der Sozialdemokrat, the party's banned newspaper.
  5. 1888Expelled from Switzerland under German pressure and moves to London.
  6. 1895Named one of Friedrich Engels's literary executors.
  7. 1899Publishes the book known in English as Evolutionary Socialism.
  8. 1901Returns to Germany after an arrest warrant lapses.
  9. 1902Elected to the Reichstag for Breslau-West.
  10. 1917Helps found the anti-war Independent Social Democrats (USPD).
  11. 1918Rejoins the SPD on 24 December, during the German revolution.
  12. 1932Dies in Berlin on 18 December, weeks before Hitler takes power.

From the atlas

Eduard Bernstein in time and on the map

Eduard Bernstein lived from 1850 to 1932. Borders of Time has 6 world maps from those years: 1878, 1880, 1900, 1914, 1920 and 1930.

Living at the same time, among others on this site: Thomas Edison (1847–1931), Claude Monet (1840–1926), Nikola Tesla (1856–1943), Philippe Pétain (1856–1951), Sigmund Freud (1856–1939), Gottlob Frege (1848–1925), Edmund Husserl (1859–1938), Henri Bergson (1859–1941), John Dewey (1859–1952) and Wilhelm II (1859–1941).

Events of those years: Little Ice Age (1303–1850), American Indian Wars (1622–1924), Sakoku (1639–1854), Fula jihads (1725–1860), Indian independence movement (1757–1947), Australian frontier wars (1794–1899), Underground Railroad (1800–1863), Romanticism (1800–1900), Circassian genocide (1800–1864) and Unification of Italy (1815–1871).

Born just before and after, among others on this site: before, Menelik II (1844–1913) and Muhammad Ahmad (1844–1885); after, Emperor Meiji (1852–1912) and Cecil Rhodes (1853–1902).

Quick answers

When was Eduard Bernstein born, and when did Eduard Bernstein die?
Eduard Bernstein was born in 1850 in Schöneberg and died in 1932 in Berlin, aged about 82.
Who was Eduard Bernstein?
Eduard Bernstein was a German socialist who, at the end of the 19th century, argued that Marx had been wrong about the coming collapse of capitalism and that socialism should be built by democratic reform.
What did Bernstein's revisionism argue?
Revisionism was Bernstein's call to revise Marx's predictions in the light of facts. He pointed out that capitalism was not collapsing, the middle class was not vanishing and workers' living standards were rising. He concluded that socialists should win power through elections, trade unions and reforms, step by step, rather than wait for a revolution.
What did Bernstein mean by "the movement is everything"?
In a reply to his critics he wrote that he had very little interest in the "final goal" of socialism, and that what mattered to him was the movement itself. He meant the everyday struggle for better wages, laws and democratic rights. Opponents seized on the phrase as proof that he had given up on socialism altogether.
How did Rosa Luxemburg respond to Bernstein?
In her pamphlet Social Reform or Revolution? (1899) she argued that reforms alone could never end capitalism, and that Bernstein's approach would turn socialists into mere improvers of the existing order. She accepted the value of reforms and democracy, but only as means towards a revolutionary change of society.