Borders of Time

Event

Guelphs and Ghibellines

The Guelphs and Ghibellines were the two great factions that divided the city-states of northern and central Italy from the 12th to the 15th century.

Event · 1120 CE – 1390 CE

Charles V. Monin · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
1839 Monin Map of Ancienne Italy Atlas Universel de Géographie Ancienne and Moderne

1839 Monin Map of Ancienne Italy Atlas Universel de Géographie Ancienne and Moderne

Charles V. Monin · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Date
12th to 15th centuries; fiercest c. 1230–1320
Location
Northern and central Italy, especially Tuscany
Belligerents
Guelphs (pro-papal) v. Ghibellines (pro-imperial)
Leaders
Popes, Frederick II, Manfred, Charles of Anjou
Result
Guelph dominance in Tuscany after 1266
Hear the whole article read aloud
Artist's conception of the defence of the Carroccio during the Battle of Legnano (1176), painted by Amos Cassioli (1832–1891)
The original uploader was Faberh at Italian Wikipedia . · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Artist's conception of the defence of the Carroccio during the Battle of Legnano (1176), painted by Amos Cassioli (1832–1891)

Artist's conception of the defence of the Carroccio during the Battle of Legnano (1176), painted by Amos Cassioli (1832–1891)

The original uploader was Faberh at Italian Wikipedia . · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The Guelphs and Ghibellines were the two great factions that divided the city-states of northern and central Italy from the 12th to the 15th century. In broad terms Guelphs backed the papacy and Ghibellines backed the Holy Roman Empire in a long contest over who should dominate Italy. In practice the names became banners for every kind of local rivalry, between noble families, between nobles and merchants, and between neighbouring cities, and the feud shaped the politics of Florence, Siena, Pisa and Milan and the life of the poet Dante.

German names, Italian quarrels

The medieval towers of San Gimignano, built by rival aristocratic families as fortified residences
Simone Tinella · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
The medieval towers of San Gimignano, built by rival aristocratic families as fortified residences

The medieval towers of San Gimignano, built by rival aristocratic families as fortified residences

Simone Tinella · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The names came from Germany. The Welfs, dukes of Bavaria and Saxony, and the Hohenstaufen, dukes of Swabia, competed for the imperial crown in the 12th century. Tradition has it that at the siege of Weinsberg in 1140 the Welf side shouted the family name and the Hohenstaufen side shouted "Waiblingen", the name of one of their castles. In Italian these became Guelfo and Ghibellino.

The deeper roots lay in the struggle between popes and emperors that had begun with the Investiture Controversy in the late 11th century. Italy was nominally part of the empire, but its cities had grown rich and self-governing, and the popes, as rulers of the Papal States in central Italy, did not want an emperor who was master of both north and south.

Barbarossa and Frederick II

Battle of Montaperti, workshop of Pacino di Buonaguida
Giovanni Villani · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Battle of Montaperti, workshop of Pacino di Buonaguida

Battle of Montaperti, workshop of Pacino di Buonaguida

Giovanni Villani · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The first great clash came under Frederick Barbarossa, who tried to reassert imperial rights over the cities of Lombardy. They formed the Lombard League, allied with the pope and defeated him at Legnano in 1176, after which he recognised their self-government under his overlordship.

The factions took their classic shape in the reign of his grandson, Frederick II, who was also king of Sicily and so threatened to surround the papacy from both sides. The popes excommunicated him repeatedly, and from 1237 he fought a long war against the revived Lombard League. In these decades the Italian names Guelph and Ghibelline came into common use for the papal and imperial parties. Cities lined up in rival networks: Florence, Genoa and Milan generally Guelph; Siena and Pisa generally Ghibelline. Within each city, the losing families were often driven into exile, where they plotted their return.

Florence and Siena

Battle of Campaldino on a fresco in San Gimignano
Carlomarinobuttazzo at Italian Wikipedia · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Battle of Campaldino on a fresco in San Gimignano

Battle of Campaldino on a fresco in San Gimignano

Carlomarinobuttazzo at Italian Wikipedia · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Florence was the centre of the drama. Florentine writers traced the city's division to quarrels among its leading families in the early 13th century, and control of the city changed hands several times. In Florence and elsewhere the Guelphs tended to draw on merchants and bankers, the Ghibellines on older noble families, though there were many exceptions.

After Frederick II died in 1250, the Ghibelline cause passed to his son Manfred, who ruled the Kingdom of Sicily. On 4 September 1260 the Ghibellines of Siena, joined by exiled Florentine Ghibellines and backed by Manfred, routed the Florentine Guelph army at Montaperti, one of the bloodiest battles of medieval Italy. Florence's Guelphs went into exile and the Ghibellines ruled the city. Sienese sports fans still shout "Remember Montaperti!" at their Florentine rivals. The battle also left its mark on art: the Florentine painter Coppo di Marcovaldo, captured there, is said to have painted a Madonna for a Sienese church to win his freedom.

The Angevin reversal

The Holy Roman Empire when the Golden Bull of 1356 was signed
Cameron Pauley · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
The Holy Roman Empire when the Golden Bull of 1356 was signed

The Holy Roman Empire when the Golden Bull of 1356 was signed

Cameron Pauley · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The papacy answered by bringing in a new champion. Charles of Anjou, brother of Louis IX of France, accepted the Sicilian crown from the pope, and at Benevento in 1266 his army destroyed Manfred's, Manfred himself dying in the fighting. The Guelphs swept back into Florence that year and never lost it again. In 1268 Charles destroyed the last Hohenstaufen, Conradin, and the Angevins became the military backbone of the Guelph cause. In 1289 the Tuscan Guelphs crushed the Ghibellines of Arezzo at Campaldino. When Sicily rebelled against Charles in 1282, the War of the Sicilian Vespers pitted the Angevins against Aragon, which drew support from Ghibellines.

Black and White

With the Ghibellines beaten, Florence's Guelphs split. By about 1300 the city was divided between the Blacks, led by the Donati family and close to the pope, and the Whites, led by the Cerchi and more resistant to papal influence. Dante, a White, served as one of the city's priors in 1300 and opposed the ambitions of Pope Boniface VIII. In 1301 Boniface sent the French prince Charles of Valois to Florence as a peacemaker; the Blacks used his presence to seize power and in 1302 condemned the leading Whites. Dante was sentenced to exile and later to death if he returned, and never saw Florence again.

In exile Dante looked to the emperor Henry VII, who came to Italy in 1310 to restore imperial authority. Henry was disgusted by both parties, made little progress and died in 1313. The poet's bitterness at faction runs through the Divine Comedy, which recalls the slaughter at Montaperti and finds room in hell for political enemies of every party, Boniface VIII among them.

Long afterlife

After the early 14th century the original issue faded, since emperors rarely intervened in Italy in force. The labels survived as names for local parties and family alliances. Henry VII's expedition and that of Louis IV in 1327 briefly revived the Ghibelline cause, and in the 15th century the names were still invoked in Milan and elsewhere, until the French and Spanish invasions of the Italian Wars after 1494 swept the old divisions aside. Even castle walls were sometimes said to declare loyalty: in later tradition, square battlements marked a Guelph building and swallow-tailed ones a Ghibelline.

On our maps

Our maps do not draw individual Italian city-states at this period. The 1200 and 1279 maps show the Holy Roman Empire across northern Italy, the Papal States in the centre and, on the 1279 map, Sicily in the south, the main powers whose rivalry the factions served.

Key dates

  1. 1140At the siege of Weinsberg the rival German houses of Welf and Hohenstaufen are said to use the battle cries that later named the factions.
  2. 1176The Lombard League of north Italian cities defeats Emperor Frederick Barbarossa at Legnano.
  3. 1237Emperor Frederick II invades northern Italy to crush the cities of the revived Lombard League.
  4. 1250Frederick II dies, leaving the Ghibelline cause to his sons Conrad IV and Manfred.
  5. 1260Ghibelline Siena routs Guelph Florence at Montaperti on 4 September.
  6. 1266Charles of Anjou defeats and kills Manfred at Benevento, and the Guelphs return to power in Florence.
  7. 1289The Tuscan Guelphs defeat the Ghibellines at Campaldino.
  8. 1302Black Guelphs, backed by Pope Boniface VIII, exile the White Guelphs from Florence, among them Dante.
  9. 1310Emperor Henry VII enters Italy, briefly reviving Ghibelline hopes.

From the atlas

Guelphs and Ghibellines in time and on the map

Guelphs and Ghibellines lasted from 1120 to 1390. Borders of Time has 3 world maps from those years: 1200, 1279 and 1300. The nearest maps from before and after are 1100 and 1400; compare them side by side.

Living through it, among others on this site: Lalibela (1200–1300), Jayavarman VII (1122–1218), Madhvacharya (1190–1278), Orhan (1281–1362), Eleanor of Aquitaine (1124–1204), Kublai Khan (1215–1294), Ibn Arabi (1165–1240), Gajah Mada (1290–1364), Subutai (1175–1248) and Averroes (Ibn Rushd) (1126–1198).

Other events of the same years: Reconquista (722–1492), House of Wisdom (800–1258), Christianization of Scandinavia (800–1200), Investiture Controversy (1075–1124), Crusades (1095–1291), Norman conquest of southern Italy (1100–1200), Concordat of Worms (1122), Jingkang incident (1125–1127), The Anarchy (1135–1154) and Siege of Lisbon (1147) (1147).

Next to it in time on this site: before, Siege of Jerusalem (1099) (1099) and Domesday Book; after, Anglo-Norman invasion of Ireland (1169–1175) and Battle of Legnano (1176).

Quick answers

When did the Guelphs and Ghibellines happen?
It began in 1120 and ended in 1390, lasting about 270 years.
Where did the Guelphs and Ghibellines take place?
Italian Peninsula.
How did the map change?
Compare the atlas’s maps of 1100 and 1400 side by side.
How did the Guelphs differ from the Ghibellines?
In principle the Guelphs supported the pope and the Ghibellines the Holy Roman Emperor in the struggle for power in Italy. In practice the labels often covered local rivalries between families, guilds and neighbouring cities, and a city's choice of side frequently depended on which side its nearest rival had taken.
Was Dante a Guelph or a Ghibelline?
Dante was a Guelph, from the White faction that tried to limit Pope Boniface VIII's influence over Florence. When the Black Guelphs seized power in 1301 to 1302 he was exiled, and in exile he came to pin his hopes on the emperor Henry VII, which is why he is sometimes wrongly described as a Ghibelline.
Where do the names Guelph and Ghibelline come from?
Guelph is an Italian form of Welf, the German ducal family of Bavaria and Saxony, and Ghibelline comes from Waiblingen, a castle of the rival Hohenstaufen dynasty. According to a traditional story the two names were shouted as battle cries at the siege of Weinsberg in 1140, and Italians later borrowed them for their own parties.