Madhvacharya, usually called Madhva, was a thirteenth-century Hindu philosopher from the coast of Karnataka in southern India. Against the dominant teaching that the soul and God are ultimately one, he argued that God, individual souls and the material world are eternally and really different, a position known as Dvaita, "dualism". His school became one of the three great schools of Vedanta, alongside the Advaita of Adi Shankara and the qualified non-dualism of Ramanuja, and his monastic successors still keep the Krishna temple he founded at Udupi.
Dates and sources
Madhva's life is known from a Sanskrit biography, the Madhvavijaya, written by the son of one of his disciples, and from later tradition. Both are full of miracles. His dates are disputed. Many modern scholars, following B. N. K. Sharma, place him between 1238 and 1317, while older reckonings give about 1199 to 1278, and reference works still differ.
Early life and training
He was born Vasudeva, the son of a Tulu-speaking Brahmin, Madhyageha Bhatta, and his wife, usually named as Vedavati, at Pajaka, a village near Udupi on the west coast. Stories say he was a strong, athletic boy with a fine voice and a quick memory, who loved swimming and wrestling. His parents hoped their only surviving son would stay to support them, so he waited until a younger brother was born before becoming a monk.
His teacher was Achyutapreksha, head of a monastery at Udupi that followed Shankara's Advaita, or non-dualism. At his initiation he received the name Purnaprajna, and later Anandatirtha; he used these names and "Madhva" in his works. Even as a student he is said to have questioned his teacher's interpretations, and he soon developed his own reading of the scriptures.
Travels and debates
Madhva toured south India, debating with Advaita scholars and other teachers. His tradition remembers fierce clashes with monks of the Shankara monastery at Sringeri, and at one point his library was stolen and returned only after a local prince intervened. He travelled north at least twice, to Badrinath in the Himalayas, where his followers believe he met the legendary sage Vyasa, compiler of the Vedas and author of the Brahma Sutras, who approved his interpretation. In time he is said to have won his own teacher over to his views.
Back at Udupi he installed an image of Krishna, traditionally rescued from a wrecked ship off the nearby coast, and placed its worship in the care of eight monasteries headed by his disciples. The Udupi Krishna Matha remains the centre of the Madhva tradition. Late in life, according to tradition, he set out again for Badrinath and was never seen again.
Dvaita: the philosophy of difference
Madhva's central claim was that difference is real. He listed five basic differences: between God and souls, between God and matter, between souls and matter, between one soul and another, and between one piece of matter and another. Only God, whom he identified with Vishnu, is independent. Souls and matter exist only in dependence on God, and that very dependence makes them forever distinct from him.
He defended this partly by appealing to ordinary experience. We perceive ourselves as separate from one another and from God, and Madhva held that perception and reasoning are trustworthy; if they were not, we could not trust our reading of the scriptures either. He therefore rejected Advaita's claim that the world's variety is a product of maya, illusion. His most famous move was a new reading of a celebrated line of the Chandogya Upanishad, usually read as "you are that", meaning the self is Brahman. By dividing the Sanskrit words differently he read it as "you are not that".
For Madhva, liberation from rebirth comes only through bhakti, loving devotion to Vishnu, and through God's grace. He also taught, unusually for Hindu thought, that souls differ by nature and are destined for different ends: some for liberation, some for continued rebirth, and some for darkness. The philosopher Valerie Stoker notes that this put him at odds with the usual idea that karma alone explains differences between beings.
Monasteries and successors
Madhva built an institution as well as a doctrine. The eight Udupi monasteries he entrusted to his disciples, among them Palimaru, Adamaru, Krishnapura, Puttige, Shirur, Sodhe, Kaniyooru and Pejavara, still take turns in running the Krishna temple under a rotation known as the paryaya, with its order of succession and study traced back to Madhva himself. To carry the teaching beyond the Tulu-speaking coast he gave a separate charge to another disciple, Padmanabha Tirtha, and named the monks who were to follow him in turn. The monasteries of the Deccan descend from that line, above all the Uttaradi Matha and two later branches, the Vyasaraja Matha and the Raghavendra Matha, often counted together as the three chief seats of Dvaita. His theory of knowledge rested on three sources, perception, inference and the testimony of reliable authority, of which the Vedas were the highest.
Writings
Tradition credits Madhva with 37 works in Sanskrit. They include commentaries on the three foundations of Vedanta, namely the main Upanishads, the Brahma Sutras and the Bhagavad Gita, as well as on parts of the Rigveda, the Mahabharata and the Bhagavata Purana. His Anuvyakhyana, a verse supplement to his Brahma Sutra commentary, is often considered his masterpiece.
Legacy
Later thinkers made Dvaita a formidable philosophical system. Jayatirtha, who lived from about 1345 to 1388, wrote the classic commentaries on Madhva's works, and Vyasatirtha in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries sharpened its arguments against Advaita. Kannada poet-saints of the Haridasa movement, such as Purandaradasa, carried Madhva's devotion to ordinary people in simple devotional songs in their own language. Some traditions also link the Bengali saint Chaitanya's lineage to Madhva's order, although that connection is debated. Today the Madhva community, centred on Udupi and its monasteries, is one of the living schools of Hinduism and an important voice in Indian philosophy.
On our maps
Our 1279 and 1300 maps show the Chola and Pandya kingdoms of the far south in Madhva's lifetime; the smaller coastal territory around Udupi where he lived is not drawn separately.
Key dates
- c. 1238Vasudeva, the future Madhva, is born at Pajaka near Udupi; an older dating gives 1199.
- c. 1250As a youth he becomes a monk under Achyutapreksha, a teacher of Shankara's Advaita school.
- c. 1285He installs an image of Krishna at Udupi, the centre of his movement ever since.
- c. 1317He leaves on a final journey north and is never seen again, according to tradition.
- c. 1345Jayatirtha, the school's great commentator, is born; he lives until about 1388.
- c. 1370The later teacher Jayatirtha writes commentaries that make Dvaita a full philosophical system.
- c. 1388Jayatirtha dies; his successors carry the commentary tradition into the monasteries of the Deccan.
- c. 1500Vyasatirtha and the Kannada poet-saints of the Haridasa movement spread his teaching.
From the atlas
Madhvacharya in time and on the map
Madhvacharya lived from 1190 to 1278. Borders of Time has one world map from those years: 1200.
Living at the same time, among others on this site: Lalibela (1200–1300), Nasir al-Din al-Tusi (1201–1273), Rumi (1207–1273), Sundiata Keita (1190–1255), Béla IV of Hungary (1206–1270), Daniel of Galicia (1201–1264), Kublai Khan (1215–1294), Subutai (1175–1248), Frederick II (1194–1250) and Louis IX of France (1214–1270).
Events of those years: Reconquista (722–1492), House of Wisdom (800–1258), Christianization of Scandinavia (800–1200), Crusades (1095–1291), Norman conquest of southern Italy (1100–1200), Guelphs and Ghibellines (1120–1390), Third Crusade (1189–1192), Siege of Acre (1189–1191) (1189–1191), First Battle of Tarain (1191) and Second Battle of Tarain (1192).
Born just before and after, among others on this site: before, Ögedei Khan (1186–1241) and Ivan Asen II (1190–1241); after, Dōgen (1200–1253) and Batu Khan (1205–1255).
Quick answers
- When was Madhvacharya born, and when did Madhvacharya die?
- Madhvacharya was born in 1190 in Pajaka and died in 1278, aged about 88.
- Who was Madhvacharya?
- Madhvacharya, usually called Madhva, was a thirteenth-century Hindu philosopher from the coast of Karnataka in southern India.
- How does Dvaita differ from Advaita?
- Advaita, taught by Shankara, holds that the individual self is ultimately identical with Brahman, the one reality, and that the world's variety is a kind of illusion. Madhva's Dvaita says the opposite: God, souls and matter are really and eternally different, and souls depend on God completely. Liberation comes through devotion and God's grace, not through realising one's identity with God.
- How did Madhvacharya die?
- Nobody knows. Tradition says that late in life he set out for Badrinath in the Himalayas and disappeared, and his followers believe he lives on there with the sage Vyasa. The traditional date is 1317, or 1278 on the older chronology.
- Was Madhva influenced by Christianity?
- Some earlier scholars suggested so, because some stories about Madhva resemble Gospel episodes and a Christian settlement was thought to have existed near Udupi, though no evidence of one has been found. The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy notes that current scholarly opinion instead explains his ideas by the political and social changes of his own region.
- Why is Madhva seen as an incarnation of Vayu?
- Madhva presented himself as an avatar of Vayu, the wind god, who in his theology is Vishnu's chief servant and mediator for souls. His followers believe he was the third incarnation of Vayu, after Hanuman and Bhima of the epics.